Story heavy cozy-adjacent games for PC
With cozy-adjacent I genuinely mean if you can use wand (wemod) to be invincible or at least a lot stronger then that's good enough for me. As long as the game in general isn't pure horror or anything.
I just finished My Time at Sandrock and I have no idea what to play next. I love traditionally cozy games and farming games, but I've realized I need something with more of a story right now to feel excited about gaming. I'll list some games I love just to give you an idea.
Coral Island, Stardew Valley, Roots of Pacha, Cozy Grove, Disney Dreamlight Valley, Fran Bow, all the Nancy Drew games, Don't Starve (and Together), Spiritfarer, Minecraft, The Long Dark, Skyrim.
I also own Fields of Mistria and Paleo Pines but wasn't able to get into them. I've tried My Time at Portia since that'd be the obvious choice but wasn't even remotely able to get into it, and I tried twice. I love The Forest and after I'd finished it vanilla with friends I played it alone and turned off enemies just so I could chill while hunting animals and cutting down trees to make a base with.
However, a lot of these games just don't have enough of a story to keep me entertained for long.
Bonus if you can have a house of some kind and there's some form of romance but not a must. Bonus if you can create your own character. Massive bonus if you can play with a controller. It can be pixel or cartoon or more realistic or whatever. 2D or 3D. It's fine if it has some puzzles, as long as they're not ridiculously hard.
I own and have heard great things about Graveyard Keeper, but I've also heard that it's ridiculously hard if you don't keep looking at the wiki as you get started and I don't really feel like having to do that all the time.
I have a relatively good gaming PC.
Any suggestions would be helpful so I can dive into something new! Thanks!