u/AdditionalList6000

▲ 6 r/Forex+1 crossposts

I’ve been in the FX trenches for 9 years. I’ve seen market cycles, blown accounts, hit streaks, and eventually found a manual edge that worked. But I’m also a business owner, and I realised I was spending too much emotional energy staring at candles. I wanted my time and life back.

I’m not a professional coder, but I know how the market moves. Over the last few months, I’ve used AI-assisted coding to bridge the gap—taking my manual trend strategy and porting it into a Python/MT5 bot.

The Data (The 13-Year Proof): I didn't just test this on a few months of data. I ran the logic through everything from 2012 to late 2024. The results confirmed what I suspected: Quality over Quantity wins.

https://preview.redd.it/s250382whayg1.png?width=915&format=png&auto=webp&s=c016ff549579fefd862fa5b678cec20fc6625600

Across 2,614 trades, the system maintained a Profit Factor of 1.76 and a Total Return of +941.6R.

Block Trades Total R Win Rate PF
2012–2014 624 +229.3R 45.4% 1.76
2015–2017 611 +243.2R 49.8% 1.85
2018–2020 596 +196.5R 43.1% 1.67
2021–2023 570 +168.2R 44.6% 1.62
2024 213 +104.3R 51.6% 2.16
TOTAL 2,614 +941.6R 46.2% 1.76

I’m at a crossroads with two versions of the logic:

  • The Sniper: Only trades the 'Institutional Windows' I’ve watched for 9 years. It averages about 45.4% to 51.6% win rate, depending on the year. It’s boring and selective, but the equity curve is a straight line.
  • Maxr: Takes every valid signal 24/5. The total profit is higher, but the drawdowns (like the -20.62R seen make it a much harder psychological ride.

All 6 sessions 24/7 (2022-2024):

Metric Sniper Max
Trades ~544 1,089
Total R ~+180R +361R
Profit Factor ~1.65 1.67
Max Drawdown ~-12R -20.62R

If you were finally stepping away from the screen after nearly a decade, would you go for the steady "Sniper" or the high-growth "Max"?

I finally pulled the trigger and went live with the "Sniper" version this week. I’m not here to post wins only; I’m here to be transparent about the transition from manual to algo, and if it is indeed feasible.

I’ll be doing a Weekly Rundown every Monday to share the raw results, the execution snags I hit with the Python-MT5 bridge (I already hit one on trade #1!), and how the live data tracks 

reddit.com
u/AdditionalList6000 — 15 days ago