I work for a smallish nonprofit, with just over 50 employees. Due to rising insurance costs, we have been working towards signing with a PEO. ADP and Paychex have given us very similar proposals, both have pros and cons. We really need to make a decision very soon, and I'm curious if anyone here has experience to share about either company's PEO.
The ADP rep that we've been working with has been surprisingly negative towards Paychex, which is a concern- but her negativity also makes me wonder if there are things that we just don't know yet. We've met with many people from the ADP team, but only the sales rep for Paychex (this bothers me!).
I'm really looking for any experience- good or bad- with these PEOs, especially if you've used both. Thank you for anything you can offer!