I'm trying to develop a panel show gimmick with improvised PowerPoint presentations as the centerpiece
This has been a nut I've been trying to crack for a while. I have a background in marketing, and have often had to prepare PowerPoint presentations and present them to audiences. Sometimes I had to present things other people put together, and sometimes my staff would have to present things I put together. This is where the kernel of the idea came from. I'm pretty good at improvising in presentations, and I enjoyed giving presentations that felt a bit off the cuff.
So originally I thought maybe there would be a way to make a game out of "PowerPoint Improv" as a training tool for my staff to give them experience presenting and help them learn to adapt. I could never figure out how to make it work, though. As a game, I wanted it to be fun and creative. I didn't want to just give them real presentations and have them rehash stuff we all sort of already know because that just turns into "rehearsal" which is already how people often train for presenting.
Skip to a decade later: I'm a big fan of panel shows, and I realize that maybe this gimmick would work in the world of panel shows. The challenge is still the same, though. How do you make a game out of it?
Have you seen anything like this? Do you have any ideas? The only thing I've seen that's close is Impractical Jokers where some tasks would involve them giving a presentation which they hadn't seen before. The "problem" there is that the audience they're presenting to believes it will be an authentic presentation, and it's very much not fun for them in the moment because of the embarrassment and awkwardness. I'm not opposed to pursuing something like that, but I would rather lean more toward traditional panel show format. I'm thinking something a bit like WILTY but instead of telling a story, you're showing a PowerPoint. The true/lie thing wouldn't work though since the point would be it's all bullshit/lie all the time.
Something that feels a bit in the right vein to me is QI. If you consider the screens behind them, it's sort of like a presentation and even though the host is reading scripted questions and facts, the "slides" often prompt discussion from the panel.
I'd appreciate some help here brainstorming this out. I want something where a person "presents" slides they haven't seen before, but to an audience that knows this, and somehow hilarity ensues.