I KNOW, just shoot me now for having even a percent of a modicum of a "Pro AI" stance. I'm prepared for the downvotes but, maybe just hear me out first...
Copilot on Xbox was the most interesting thing that Xbox has announced in the last decade. It had the POTENTIAL to be genuinely cool, depending on how it was implemented and how advanced it got.
Imagine a world where Xbox feed this AI every single bit of information about their games, this AI is integrated into the game on a development level. This AI knows everything about their games. This AI has access to things like; where your character is, how far along they are in a game, what they've unlocked and haven't etc. Imagine this scenario; you're playing X exclusive, you see a collectible and can't seem to reach it no matter what. "Hey Copilot, is this even obtainable right now" and it then uses all of the information is has to see where you are, what collectible is nearby, what you need to obtain it. It just so happens so and so unlockable ability is required and, since it is given access to your game/character, it sees you don't have that yet, it knows you will unlock it later so, it tells you not to worry about that now, keep progressing. You can and should get it later.
Now that is some insane, advanced level stuff, I know that. That's not what they were advertising BUT, at some point it could have MAYBE became that. And that's cool, that's interesting. That's an actual use for AI that can subsidise the development costs. Like how Gemini might stand some sort of chance as it's so integrated with Pixel devices. They now aren't spending stupid money to sell monthly subscriptions, they're creating a selling point for their phones. That's a console selling point that Sony can't match because they aren't Microsoft.
And before you tell me; "No one wants that", PLEASE go and ask your less tech savvy, perhaps more casual gamer friends/family just how often they now use ChatGPT or Google Gemini. I bet it is much more than you'd think. I have my tech illiterate mother asking me to download ChatGPT on her phone because her, ALSO tech illiterate, friends use it and say it's helpful. Xbox you are a console maker and the people, the ones you want to sell millions of consoles to, LIKE A HELPFUL AI.
I think axing it is indicative of the new mindset that Asha Sharma seems to have brought in, for now. That being; "Say what gets us the most brownie points online, worry about the rest later"...
Yes, cancelling Copilot on consoles has gotten some news articles and you're being upvoted on Reddit BUT, that is at the cost of the most interesting feature you potentially had, one that your competitor could not match and one that could help subsidise the entire Copilot program with Xbox sales? All to please a vocal minority, in the short term. At the end of the day, all CANCELLING that feature does is generate short term buzz in the online spaces that your target demographic do not frequent. It will not bring in sales.
And yes, I stand by that they should not be trying to appeal to the technical gamer that spends their time on Reddit and hates AI. They did that when they made the Series X more powerful than a PS5, when they gave it x amount more teraflops and whatever. It didn't work.
I'm seeing so much praise for Xbox recently but, it's all just noise. It's a new logo and new start up, all while the homepage that loads up after is still full of ads. It's a cheaper Gamepass but, behind that is less day one releases? The next CoD will not be on Gamepass. That's fine if you don't like CoD but, that's also not the point. They didn't make Gamepass cheaper because "they care", they're offering less. They're sacrificing what could have a really cool thing for Reddit upvotes. Just my thoughts.
And just before you attempt to tell me ALL about the privacy concerns of my proposed AI; see my previous comment.